Three years ago today, on the morning of October 7, 2023, Hamas terrorists poured out of Gaza into the towns and farming villages of southern Israel. It was the Sabbath, and it was a feast day. By nightfall nearly 1,200 people had been murdered, most of them civilians and the great majority of them Jews. Families were shot and burned in their own homes. Young people were hunted down at a music festival. Another 251 were dragged back into Gaza as hostages, babies and grandmothers among them. It was the deadliest day for the Jewish people since the Holocaust.

We remember them today, and we grieve with those who are still grieving.

You would think a day like that would settle some things. It hasn't. Three years later, hatred of the Jews is out in the open in a way many of us never expected to see in our lifetime. The Anti-Defamation League counted 6,274 antisemitic incidents in the United States in 2025. That was down from the record set the year before, but physical assaults reached the highest number the ADL has ever recorded, and last year brought the first antisemitic murders in this country since 2019. Some of the ugliest talk I have seen didn't come from the world, either. It came from people who call themselves Christians.

Terrible Jews and Strange Dispensationalists

When anything happens in Israel, I do enjoy learning the eschatology of my friends and followers on social media, even when it is something I disagree with. This time around it seems like the volume is way up. I'm not sure whether some of y'all are angrier with the Jews or with the dispensationalists.

No doubt there are some terrible Jews, just like there are terrible Gentiles. There are some strange dispensationalists too, just like there are strange people in every camp. The modern state of Israel is governed by sinners like every other nation on earth, and a Christian is free to disagree with its leaders. Disagreeing with a government is one thing. What I keep seeing online is something else: contempt for the Jewish people as a people, and a sneer for anybody who says God still has a purpose for Israel.

Replacement theology teaches that the church has taken Israel's place and inherited the promises God made to her. It is a major part of Reformed theology, so maybe I understand the passion on the subject, even though I very much disagree with it. What I can't let pass is the claim, repeated so often these days, that believing God has a future for ethnic Israel is a novelty cooked up in the 1830s by John Nelson Darby and spread by the Scofield Reference Bible in 1909.

That claim is false. Long before Scofield or Darby, there were Baptist men, and even Reformed men, who took the Bible literally and believed that God was not finished with the Jews according to the promises He gave them.

There are heresies out there we must fight, but taking Yahweh's promises to Israel literally is not one of them.

A Cloud of Witnesses

As I was looking through some of my own resources in Logos Bible Software, I came across a page someone had shared on Facebook. I lost track of who posted it, but I have since found the original. It is a compilation by Phil Layton titled Noted Theologians in History Who Believed in a Future Conversion of National/Ethnic Israel, and it draws on the work of Iain Murray, Barry Horner, and Michael Vlach. It is published at Monergism, which is a Reformed website. Keep that in mind as you read.

What follows is a sampling. These men disagreed among themselves about the millennium and about the land, and Layton is careful to say he isn't claiming they all believed the same thing. What they shared was this: when Paul wrote that all Israel will be saved, every one of them believed he meant Israel.

The Reformation and the Geneva Bible

Iain Murray, a Reformed historian who was no premillennialist, traced this hope back to the first generation of the Reformation in Britain. Martin Bucer at Cambridge and Peter Martyr at Oxford both taught that the Jews would one day be called, and Theodore Beza, Calvin's own successor at Geneva, followed them. In 1560, four years before Calvin died, the English exiles who produced the Geneva Bible put this note in the margin at Romans 11:26:

He sheweth that the time shall come that the whole nation of the Jews, though not every one particularly, shall be joined to the church of Christ. Geneva Bible, marginal note on Romans 11:26 (1560)

The Puritans

By the 1620s, Murray found, the expectation of a coming conversion of the Jews had become common ground among the English Puritans. William Perkins, one of the most widely read of them, reasoned straight from God's promise to Abraham in Genesis 12:

The Lord saith, All the nations shall be blessed in Abraham: Hence I gather that the nation of the Jews shall be called, and converted to the participation of this blessing: when, and how, God knows: but that it shall be done before the end of the world we know. William Perkins (1558–1602), as cited in Iain Murray, The Puritan Hope

The Westminster Assembly wrote the same hope into the prayers of the church. The Larger Catechism says that when we pray "Thy kingdom come," we are asking for "the gospel propagated throughout the world, the Jews called, the fulness of the Gentiles brought in." The Directory for Public Worship told ministers to pray from the pulpit "for the conversion of the Jews, the fulness of the Gentiles." Think about that for a minute. The very men many of our Reformed brethren look to as their fathers were leading their congregations in prayer for the salvation of Israel.

John Owen, preaching before the House of Commons in 1649, spoke of "the bringing home of his ancient people to be one fold with the fulness of the Gentiles." Thomas Goodwin warned his hearers that some of their prayers might not be answered in their own lifetime, and he named "those you haply make for the calling of the Jews" among them. Then he comforted them that such prayers "are not yet lost, but will be answered." In Scotland, Thomas Boston preached a sermon in 1716 titled "Encouragement to Pray for the Conversion of the Jews," telling his people there was a day coming "when there shall be a national conversion of the Jews or Israelites."

The Baptists

Our own Baptist forefathers stood right alongside them. John Gill pastored the same London congregation that Charles Spurgeon would later pastor. When Gill came to Romans 11:26, he said Paul meant "not the mystical spiritual Israel of God, consisting both of Jews and Gentiles," but "the people of the Jews, the generality of them, the body of that nation." Robert Haldane, the Scottish evangelist who embraced Baptist convictions, wrote the same thing in his exposition of Romans: "Then the people of Israel, as a body, shall be brought to the faith of the Gospel."

Spurgeon himself preached on Ezekiel 37 at the Metropolitan Tabernacle in June of 1864, in aid of a society for taking the gospel to the Jews. He would not let the valley of dry bones be turned into something Ezekiel never said:

The meaning of our text, as opened up by the context, is most evidently, if words mean anything, first, that there shall be a political restoration of the Jews to their own land and to their own nationality; and then, secondly, there is in the text, and in the context, a most plain declaration, that there shall be a spiritual restoration, a conversion in fact, of the tribes of Israel. C. H. Spurgeon, "The Restoration and Conversion of the Jews," Sermon 582 (1864)

He preached that eighty-four years before there was a modern state of Israel.

On Both Sides of the Atlantic

Jonathan Edwards, the great preacher of the First Great Awakening, wrote in his History of the Work of Redemption that "nothing is more certainly foretold than this national conversion of the Jews," and he pointed to Romans 11 as his proof. He saw "a kind of continual miracle" in the way God had kept the Jews a distinct people through all their centuries of scattering.

Charles Hodge of Princeton was a postmillennialist, and he put it about as plainly as it can be put: "The Jews, as a people, are now rejected; as a people they are to be restored." J. C. Ryle, the evangelical bishop of Liverpool, went further still: "I believe that the Jews shall ultimately be gathered again as a separate nation, restored to their own land, and converted to the faith of Christ, after going through great tribulation."

In 1839 the Church of Scotland sent Robert Murray M'Cheyne and Andrew Bonar on a mission of inquiry to the Jews of Palestine and Europe. M'Cheyne came home and pleaded with the churches from Romans 1:16 that the gospel is to go to the Jew first, and his preaching stirred the Irish Presbyterians to begin a mission to the Jews of their own.

Even the Amillennial Men

The conviction didn't die out in the twentieth century, even among men who had no use at all for dispensationalism. John Murray of Westminster Seminary, as Reformed a scholar as there ever was, argued in his commentary on Romans that "all Israel" has to mean the mass of ethnic Israel turned to faith, and that God's relationship to Israel as His chosen people still stands. Geerhardus Vos, the father of Reformed biblical theology, expected a sweeping conversion of Israel before the Lord's return. Martyn Lloyd-Jones and R. C. Sproul, neither of them premillennial, read Romans 11:26 the same way.

Back to Our Text

I didn't share these quotes so that you would believe something because Spurgeon said it, or Gill, or Hodge. You'll not hear me build a doctrine on any man. Layton ends his own compilation by reminding his readers that no matter which theologians we can line up on our side, the final authority is Scripture alone. He's right. So back to our text.

Paul spends three chapters of Romans on this very question, and he opens chapter 11 by asking it out loud:

I say then, has God rejected His people? May it never be! For I too am an Israelite, a seed of Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin. God has not rejected His people whom He foreknew. Romans 11:1–2 (LSB)

Has God rejected His people? May it never be! Paul offers himself as the first exhibit. Then, after warning the Gentile believers in Rome not to be wise in their own estimation, he tells them "a partial hardening has happened to Israel until the fullness of the Gentiles has come in," and he goes on:

and so all Israel will be saved; just as it is written, “The Deliverer will come from Zion,
He will remove ungodliness from Jacob.”
“And this is My covenant with them,
When I take away their sins.”
From the standpoint of the gospel they are enemies for your sake, but from the standpoint of God’s choice they are beloved for the sake of the fathers; for the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable. Romans 11:26–29 (LSB)

Who is the Israel of verse 26? Look at the chapter. It is ethnic Israel that stumbled in verse 11, ethnic Israel whose natural branches were broken off in verse 17, ethnic Israel that is partially hardened in verse 25, and ethnic Israel that is beloved for the sake of the fathers in verse 28. Paul doesn't change the meaning of the word in the middle of his argument. Hodge and Poole both made exactly that point. If "all Israel" only means all the elect, Jew and Gentile together, then Paul has called it a mystery to announce that the saved will be saved. The Puritan Elnathan Parr, whose commentary on Romans came out in 1620, asked who had ever doubted that.

Look at verse 29 again. "The gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable." Folks, most of us have used that verse to comfort a struggling believer, and rightly so. But see what Paul attaches it to. He says it about Israel, beloved for the sake of the fathers. If God can take back His calling of Israel, what makes you so sure He won't take back His calling of you? Of all people on earth, those of us who believe in sovereign election ought to be the last to say that God's choice can be undone by man's unbelief.

Jeremiah heard Yahweh stake His promise on the sun and the stars:

Thus says Yahweh, Who gives the sun for light by day
And the statutes for the moon and the stars for light by night,
Who stirs up the sea so that its waves roar;
Yahweh of hosts is His name:
“If these statutes are removed
From before Me,” declares Yahweh,
“Then the seed of Israel also will cease
From being a nation before Me forever.”
Thus says Yahweh, “If the heavens above can be measured
And the foundations of the earth searched out below,
Then I will also reject all the seed of Israel
For all that they have done,” declares Yahweh. Jeremiah 31:35–37 (LSB)

Has anybody measured the heavens yet? Did the sun come up this morning? Then God is not finished with Israel.

One more thing has to be said plainly. God's faithfulness to Israel does not mean there are two ways to be saved. No one, Jew or Gentile, comes to the Father except through Jesus Christ. The Deliverer who comes from Zion is the Lord Jesus, and when all Israel is saved, it will be by looking in faith to the One they pierced, the same way any sinner in Brunswick is saved. Every man on Layton's list understood that. That is exactly why they prayed for the conversion of the Jews. Nobody prays for the conversion of people who are already fine.

No Room for Contempt

This is where Romans 11 meets October 7. Right in the middle of the chapter, Paul stops and speaks directly to Gentile Christians:

But if some of the branches were broken off, and you, being a wild olive, were grafted in among them and became a partaker with them of the rich root of the olive tree, do not boast against the branches. But if you do boast against them, remember that it is not you who supports the root, but the root supports you. You will say then, “Branches were broken off so that I might be grafted in.” Quite right! They were broken off for their unbelief, but you stand by your faith. Do not be haughty, but fear, for if God did not spare the natural branches, He will not spare you, either. Romans 11:17–21 (LSB)

Do not boast against the branches. That is a command, brethren. Whatever you believe about the millennium, you are not permitted to look down your nose at the Jewish people. The root supports you. Every page of your Bible came to you through Jewish hands, and your Savior, according to the flesh, was a Jew.

The Romans volume of Matthew Henry's commentary, published some three hundred years ago, told Gentile believers they "must not insult and triumph over those poor Jews, but rather pity them, and desire their welfare, and long for the receiving of them in again." On verse 18 it went further: "Do not therefore trample upon the Jews as a reprobate people, nor insult over those that are broken off."

Spurgeon, preaching in December of 1863, said something about the history of Christendom that ought to shame us still:

It is perhaps the greatest of all modern miracles, that there should be one Jew upon earth who is a Christian, for the treatment they have received from pretended Christians has been enough to make them hate the name of Jesus. C. H. Spurgeon, "Once a Curse but Now a Blessing," Sermon 543 (1863)

Pretended Christians. That is the right name for a man who names the name of Christ and then talks about the Jewish people with the same venom you hear from their enemies. I don't care what his eschatology is.

Paul shows us the right posture. He took thirty-nine lashes from his own countrymen five times over and was run out of city after city, and he still wrote this:

I am telling the truth in Christ, I am not lying, my conscience testifies with me in the Holy Spirit, that I have great sorrow and unceasing grief in my heart. For I could wish that I myself were accursed, separated from Christ for the sake of my brothers, my kinsmen according to the flesh, who are Israelites, to whom belongs the adoption as sons, and the glory and the covenants and the giving of the Law and the temple service and the promises, whose are the fathers, and from whom is the Christ according to the flesh, who is God over all, blessed forever. Amen. Romans 9:1–5 (LSB)

Great sorrow and unceasing grief. That is the heart of an apostle toward the very people who wanted him dead. A chapter later he says it again: "Brothers, my heart's desire and my prayer to God for them is for their salvation" (Romans 10:1). If your heart toward the Jews is anything other than that, take it to the Lord.

Show Some Respect for the Brethren

I ask all who are interested in this subject to read through these quotes and examine the Scriptures for yourselves. Even if you come away with a different conclusion, understand that some giants of the past held the same position others hold today. Francis Turretin of Geneva, who expected Israel's conversion himself, still counseled that the details of how and when were safer left unknown than rashly defined. That is good counsel for every one of us. Hold your eschatology with conviction and your brethren with charity.

There are heresies out there we must fight. Denying the deity of Christ is one, and adding works to grace is another. Taking Yahweh's promises to Israel literally is not one of them. At least show some respect for the brethren, for the cause of Christ and the furtherance of the gospel.

Today of all days, pray for Israel. Pray for the families still grieving what was done to them three years ago, and pray as Paul prayed for the salvation of his kinsmen according to the flesh.

If you do not have a church home, we would love to have you visit us at Sovereign Grace Baptist Church in Brunswick, Georgia. You can find our service times and location at sgbcbrunswick.com/services, or contact us with any questions.